CalcYardfree · offline · no sign-up

CalcYard / Comparisons

Lease vs Buy a Car

Leasing rents depreciation for a few years; buying owns the whole asset, depreciation and all, and eventually stops costing you anything monthly.

Side by side

LeaseBuy
Monthly paymentLowerHigher
Ownership at endNone — return the carYou own it outright
Mileage limitsYes, with overage feesNone
Long-term costPayments never stopPayments stop; then just maintenance
Best forNew car every 2–3 years, low mileageKeeping a car 7+ years

Strengths of each

Lease — strengths

  • Lower monthly payment
  • Always under warranty
  • No resale hassle

Buy — strengths

  • No mileage limits
  • Builds equity
  • Cheaper over a long hold

Worked example

Leasing costs roughly $450/month indefinitely; buying the same car might be $550/month for 5 years, then $0 — buying wins decisively past year 6 or 7.

FAQ

Is leasing ever the cheaper choice?
Per-mile of use over a short horizon (2–3 years) with low mileage, yes — the math flips the longer you keep a car.

What’s the biggest hidden lease cost?
Mileage overage fees, often 15–30 cents per mile past the limit, plus wear-and-tear charges at turn-in.